Skip to content

Cultural risk review for ad campaigns

Second Look reads an ad’s picture, words and launch date against each market’s history, and cites the precedent for every flag.

Review your own ad

PNG, JPEG or WebP, up to 10MB.

Northline’s brief

MarketChina
ChannelDigital display
LaunchNot set

Takes about a minute.

Can you spot the issue?

Flag what a local audience would object to: a spot on the ad, or a line of the brief.

The creative under review

A campaign is morethan its picture.

  1. Retrieve precedent

    Documented campaign failures are ranked against the campaign's markets and wording. The analyst gets them as reference, not a checklist.

    65 documented incidents

  2. Check the calendar

    The launch date is crossed against each market's memorial, political and religious calendar. Moving holidays are flagged for local verification.

    149 dates across 15 markets

  3. Read it together

    Claude examines the name, headline, body copy, date, channel and image on their own, then in combination, and names the exact referent for anything it flags.

    Every finding cites its grounding

  4. Draft an alternative

    Findings that live in the picture compile into an art-direction note for the Magic Hour API. Copy and timing findings stay on screen.

    The request is shown in full

The picture was fine.The words weren’t.

A tumbler called the Tank, launched on May 18, with the slogan “Thwack it on the table!”

Starbucks Korea pulled the promotion within hours and fired its CEO. Nobody in the approval chain was malicious; they didn’t have the reference. The failure lived entirely in a name, a date and a slogan, which is why Second Look reads the whole campaign and not just the image.

Read the Tank Day case study

Synthetic reconstruction of the Tank Day tumbler ad, with a fictional brand

Rebuilt with a fictional brand.

  1. The white facade of the former South Jeolla Provincial Office in Gwangju, with a ginkgo tree in front and the gate plaque on the right.

    1Tank

    Martial-law troops sent tanks against pro-democracy protesters in Gwangju in 1980.

    The former South Jeolla Provincial Office in Gwangju, where the last protesters held out. Troops retook it in the early hours of May 27, 1980. Photo LERK, CC BY-SA 4.0.

  2. A long wall of framed portraits above an altar flanked by white wreaths.

    2May 18

    The anniversary of the Gwangju Democratization Movement, a national memorial day.

    Portraits of the dead in the memorial hall at the May 18th National Cemetery, Gwangju. Photo Schlarpi, CC BY-SA 3.0.

  3. A small tiled room with a bathtub, a washbasin, a narrow bed and a framed portrait of Park Jong-chul on the wall.

    3Thwack

    Echoes the 1987 police account of student activist Park Jong-chul's death under torture.

    Room 509 of the former police interrogation center at Namyeong-dong, Seoul, where Park Jong-chul died in January 1987. Police first claimed he collapsed when an investigator slammed the desk. Photo Jjw, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Buy reviews

Each review reads the picture, the words and the launch date against every market you pick, and includes one alternative from Magic Hour.

Reviews never expire. A review or alternative that fails is refunded automatically. Stripe handles the payment; Second Look never sees your card. Prices in US dollars.